OK, this is a first for me. A post that delves into…are you ready?…a controversial topic. Which is precisely why I am writing this. You see, ’tis the season to be merry, hairy, gay and bright. OK, maybe not hairy – but it IS winter. But I digress. I think we add too much controversy where there is no need. Before I go on, if you want to keep it light and fluffy..please scroll down directly to my wish for you, and thank you for stopping by!
“Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing, there is a field. I will meet you there.” Rumi
Firstly, a disclaimer. I work daily at loving and respecting all people and all religions. You could say I’m a heathen, as I do not subscribe to any one religion. :} But I feel happily open-hearted to the beautiful tenets, teachings, practices and traditions of many. As my mother immigrated to the states from Germany, we practiced many beloved Christmas traditions this time of year, including feasting on goose and defrocking the tree of the decadent chocolate ornaments she imported from Europe. Oh yes, she tried to teach us about family and love and sharing, too :). I am ignorant of much and yet I keep learning. Please excuse any clumsy offense incurred by my ramblings. I intend none at all.
Christmas is not a Bad Word
So here it is. I am tired of people tiptoeing around certain specific holiday words; you know, words like Christmas, Hanukkah, Ramadan, Diwali, and Kwanzaa. Oh my! I just said them. And all together! Before you leave in disgust, let me ‘splain. I speak of the well-meaning efforts of people who have created such a homogenized holiday season that we refer to the gloriously decorated pine trees in the center of town as a “holiday tree”. Esquueeeze me?! Is Christmas a bad word of a sudden? It’s a Christmas tree. Flocked or not, you cannot change it’s meaning and tradition. Whether you’re a practicing Christian or not, it’s a Christmas tree! Say it with me…Christ.mas.tree. See? That wasn’t too painful. Just like that candle-holder thingy? It’s a menorah. Useful in celebrating the eight days of Hanukkah. It’s not a “holiday candelabra”.
I have actually had to argue this position when I sat on a board of village business owners who, in the interest of political correctness, were considering referring to the 3-story high spruce bedecked with lights, bows and other assorted parafernalia, as a “holiday tree”. I put my foot down. I’m sorry. I cannot abide the tiptoeing that, in my eyes, in and of itself diminishes the importance of certain symbolic traditional icons. It’s well-meaningness gone very wrong. Since I moved away I suspect that conifer became known as a “holiday tree”.
Season’s Tweetings!
Don’t get me wrong. I’m all for holiday parades and holiday thises and thats. I say “Happy Holidays” as a generic blessing to people around this time of year. And “Season’s Tweetings” to my Twitter luuverlies. But if I know what holiday they observe, I try to be specific. I’m curious: If someone says, “Merry Christmas” or “Happy Hanukkah” to you, and you don’t observe either holiday, do you cringe? Or is it just like me saying, “happy Thursday!” to you? I’m actually curious how you view this and how you finesse through it. I hope it’s a given that anyone wishing you ANYthing happy is a nice thing, yes?
I cannot recall the comic/social critic who nailed it (I think maybe George Carlin) but he said something about how “there are people who go through their lives with a clipboard in hand, waiting to be offended.” Let’s put our clipboards down 🙂
Let’s celebrate the practice of celebrating. Let’s practice the tenets of these respected religions and extend love, tolerance, and appreciation to all mankind. Oh heck, womankind too! 😉
Thank you for tolerating me and my silly, under-informed ramblings. I welcome your thoughts on this subject and I ask only that you are gentle with me, as I am merely “a spiritual being having a human experience.” (Teilhard de Chardin)
* ★ ⋰˚★ ✡•.¸¸ ✴ ⋰˚☆ My Wish for You * ☆ ⋰˚★ ✡ •.¸¸✴ ⋰˚★
I wish you all a joyous time with your families, friends and loved ones. ..I wish you also quiet time to soak in what this season and its festivities mean to you…or even what they don’t mean. I wish you an abundant heart, overflowing with love for others, and most importantly, for yourself. I wish you these things not only now but throughout the year, every year. But most of all, I wish you…Peace. Namaste.
P.S. I considered not posting this for fear of offending; then I realized I was tiptoeing. I welcome a dialogue about your thoughts.
Photos by G. Stark





{ 24 comments… read them below or add one }
Thank you!!! I am so sick and tired of worrying about offending someone. You do not have the right to not be offended. I find it funny that we tip-toe around saying Merry Christmas!!! If you get offended by hearing Merry Christmas you really need to get a life.
Hellooo little Ray of Sunshine 😉 Thank you thank you for your comment. It really does come around to having a well-meaning heart, yes? Merry Christmas to you! (heehee) Bliss you! Gina
Loved your article! I agree, all this tiptoeing around in order to not offend someone takes the spirit out of all Holidays! You can celebrate your own personal holiday while respecting another's holiday. I can proudly put up my Christmas tree as I look through the window to see my neighbor's menorah and not be offended. And hopefully they won't be putting my name on their clipboard! ;} Hope you have a Merry Christmas!
Well, I LOVE your comment! Thank you! You put it so succinctly. I am enamored of the word – many of them! lol I love that part about them not logging you on their clipboard! Hi-5 :)) Merry happy Christmas to you as well. Have a blissful year! xo Gina
The first step to authentic relationships is to recognize our differences.
And to respect them.
The first step towards self-acceptance is to acknowledge who we are and where we are coming from.
And to honor that.
Thanks for posting about this!
Thank you oodles and noodles (fettucine, of course) for your comments, Paolo, and for your awesomeness as a gelato-scooper, pizza-pusher, runner/hiker appreciator, and overall enlightened dang soul! Such an honor to connect with lovely people on this here blog and T and FB :)) Cheers and Merry Christmas!! G
Thank You for addressing this! It's a subject that @terrinakamura and I have talked about quite extensively…on the phone. I think that political correctness does just the opposite of what it's purported to do. I think it breeds more hatred and adversity! If people just observed respect, kindness, and common decency; that would be enough! The world, of course; would be a better place. To quote an old adage…." Do unto others, as you would have them do unto you"!
So people….when I call myself a Tech-tard; I mean ABSOLUTELY NO disrespect to any persons of diminished mental capacity! :)))
BTW…."Merry Christmas"!!!!
Hi sweetness! Thank you for popping in and reading this and for your comments! About referring to yourself as a "tard"…I have a dear friend with a kind heart whose daughter is slightly intellectually retarded. And she refers to her as retarded! It is NOT a bad word – though we have denigrated it to an insult. She works with "challenged" children with all types of labels, and she is an awesome, loving person. I applaud her bravery and honesty in using the proper terms without daintily dancing around truths. I think much of acceptance when we hear these "controversial" terms is knowing the person's heart. These words CAN be bandied about in insensitive ways and it is up to the compassionate community to employ them boldly and lovingly! Merry Christmas dear one! Happy bonfires! 🙂 G
Amicably written truths, with honorable intentions, to give freedom to celebration! You are freeing many with these thoughts to just enjoy the magic, miracles, and goodness holidays can bring! 😉 Cultural Geography is my degree & I teach at a school with 27 languages represented. We celebrate, learn, and respect through sharing our traditions with each other. Learning about Ramadan through one student's excitement built a new bond. I called his mom to ask if he could join in a Christmas tradition I was presenting for the students and her answer, "Oh, yes he can participate. I want him to learn of customs here." Hopefully, a little more peace is built as we learn and celebrate through the traditions we all hold so dear! Calling them what they are builds new vocabulary and understanding, I'm all for it 😉
I like that so muuch!: "give freedom to celebration!" I love that the mom was open to celebrating and learning about different cultures and traditions. Bravo! Thank you so very much, Cherie, for taking the time to read and comment! You make me so glad I took the leap and the "risk" of broaching this topic. I've been heartened by the show of openness and acceptance and love. Happy happy and merry merry! 😉 Bliss you, G
Amen. Oh, am I allowed to say that if I'm a 'heathen', too? 🙂 Merry Merry, Happy Happy, and a big Ho Ho Ho! Irina
Teehee – welcome fellow heathen! You can't fool me…I know you have a loving, generous heart 😛 xoxoxo Peace and peas…Sista G
The tough part (if you ask me, which of course you didn't) is that there are secular and non-secular people who use the word Christmas, and that the word means different things to those two groups. That is fine as it goes, but the culture war between the fundamental Christians and us heathens is heating up, and the word Christmas is a battlefield.
I don't mean any harm when I say Merry Christmas (and I do say it) but I don't mean Happy Birthday Jesus.
Hi Melani! Actually I DID ask for feedback 🙂 so thanks! Good point about what it actually means to wish someone a Merry Christmas. I don't mean it in a religious way either, but with heartfelt and sincere wishes for peace, love and joy with family, friends, pets, nature…wherever God and/or love resides for you. I only hope those who are devoutly Christian aren't offended that there are many of us who celebrate the season and the traditions connected with it. But it is here and elsewhere that a (hopefully) healthy, loving and respectful dialogue can take place. Thank you for participating and offering your valuable perspective! Merry Christmas! G
I have a bunch of thoughts, in no particular order (which pretty much describes my whole life):
1. this blog entry is the reason I followed you on twitter (glad it was RTd!)
2. I like this — a lot
3. I used to work in the most Jewish of Jewish suburbs of Chicago. At our annual holiday party, my favorite thing was when the Jewish people said "Merry Christmas" to me and I said "Happy Hanukkah" to them. It always warmed my heart. I just loved it.
4. I'm a Christian and I really don't care what people wish me 🙂 And frankly, I'm annoyed by those Christians who pound their fists and stomp their feet on this subject. They don't speak for me!
5. I always say that in my head, Christmas is 1 holiday and New Years is another, and 2 or more makes plural, so "Happy Holidays" isn't a matter of political correctness; it's a matter of specificity 🙂
6. The saddest part is that in all of the arguing about the best thing to say, we seem to have lost the idea of wishing our fellow man happiness … and joy, and peace. How can those possibly be bad things?!
7. to MelaniRenee above — my family actually celebrates Jesus' birthday on Christmas Eve. We have cake and everything. My mom always said it was good for the children to understand what we were celebrating. However, I don't think I've ever thought that "Merry Christmas" meant "Happy Birthday Jesus". It means I'm wishing [the person I'm talking to] a happy holiday (that happens to be called Christmas). I'm totally fine with you saying Merry Christmas to me (or anyone else!) and not meaning "Happy Birthday Jesus" 🙂
8. Anyway, this is something I could talk about for hours — mostly in the "why do people make such a big deal about this" way, and I just wanted to say that I appreciated what you wrote, and that you encouraged a dialogue about it 🙂
Hiya Ant! 😉 I like your comments — a LOT 🙂 Thank you oodles and noodles for warming my heart. Really. I had no idea I would receive such wonderful, loving, allowing, feedback. I love adding to what Christmas means to me each year…and this year, my heart is more full than ever with love and hope…thanks in no small part to the wonderful, thoughtful, engaging people I have connected with online. Pretty amazing stuff, me thinks! Merry Christmas, dear! And thank you so very much for adding profoundly to the dialogue! xoxo Blissings! Gina
"I hope it’s a given that anyone wishing you ANYthing happy is a nice thing, yes?" Yes. Absolutely. I couldn't have said it better. I love this post.
Hi Judy! Thanks for popping over 🙂 Well…having YOU say that is quite the compliment as I consider you a truly adept wordsmith! I thoroughly enjoyed your Christmas survey…can I send the eggnog recipe to the email address listed here? Cheers and Merry Christmas! G
Sure someone wishing me Happy "anything" is a good thing, but I still find it odd when random people wish me a Merry Christmas. Odd doesn't mean bad, it just means odd.
It's one thing if I'm at a Christmas party and everyone is wishing each other a Merry Christmas, that seems to me a reasonable presumption, but it's the postal clerk or super market checker or gas station attendent or whatever stranger on the street wishing me a Merry Christmas I do indeed find odd. Again, odd, not bad.
For me on the receiving end of the kind wishes it's actually rather akin to someone offering me, a 20 year vegetarian, meat. I still see it as a kind gesture to offer me food even when it's a good friend that certainly knows better.
Happy Boxing Day! and a Merry New Year 🙂
Hey Jon! Thank you for your comments and input! I do agree, if someone knows your dietary preference or holiday observations, it is nice if they take those into account. I cannot tell you how many different dietary restrictions my friends have – no meat, no sugar, no booze, no gluten – it does get difficult to track. 🙂 I think my point is that if we all get overly worried about offending anyone, we stop wishing them well altogether (or offering them food!) . And I, for one, would be sad if we went in that direction. Maybe we can look at a greeting, such as "Merry Christmas" or "Happy Hanukkah" as the perfect cue for what that person celebrates, and we can then comfortably and more effusively respond. Happy Monday! ..and a truly wonderful New Year to you and the Goddess :))
I'm with you sista. I still can't believe I agonized last week over the simple poem I put on my blog. Congrats on your controversial post! Na na na na na na. You did it. And did it well!
~Theresa
Golly gee! It appears my reply to you went phwoooshhh and disappuured! Thank you again for visiting and cheering :)) And you KNOW I love the poem on your blog 🙂 Happy New Year dear! xo G
Sing it! We were never ones to tiptoe, we like to call it like it is. We wish our Jewish friends Happy Hanukah when it's Hanukah and wish them a Merry Christmas when it's Christmas and you know what, the people we call friends, of all different religions, don't take offence. That might be because we've surrounded ourselves with happy people but I like to think the world is changing and people are more accepting 🙂
Thanks Nat and Tim for your sharing. It's true that those who know our hearts will know that we only mean to share cheer and wish joy. I guess if we feel comfortable enough with the content of our hearts and souls, we'll be more OK with cheerfully offering good wishes…without "owning" how it may be taken. I love you guys! Merry Christmas, dammit! 😉 xoxo G